There have been a slew of musical based programmes which have gained immense popularity of late.Shows such as Airtel Super Singer,Hariyudan Naan,Ragamalika,Sangeetha Maha Yudham,Poorvika Little Superstars etc.In all these shows there is one common factor. One man's songs reigns supreme,One man's songs seems to dominate and that One Man is Maestro Ilaiyaraaja.
Infact i was just seeing an episode of Super Singer where they had recalled 5 eliminated girls who were given a final chance to show their prowess so that one of them can make it to the top 20 and all of them chose Ilaiyaraja's songs.As every girl was getting ready to sing i thought its gonna be a song from another MD and everytime i was happy to be proved wrong.Its but a known fact that IR'S songs are no joke and really help elevate your calibre(ie if you are a good singer:))
Also in Non Singing rounds i think it would be good to show interesting facts about the contestants likes and tastes in music and the reason for picking a song rather than showing them wear Make up and pose for the cameras.This is totally uncalled for in my humble opinion.:)
In Hariyudan Naan also songs of IR always seem to be donning the rounds but the sad part is the main judge Hariharan seems to have least knowledge about IR'S songs.It is kind of baffling that he seems to be unaware of such gems of Raja's. Also they had a round called Golden 80's where 95% of the songs were Raja's , the sad part is there were so many late 70's songs also picked up from movies such as 16 Vayathinile (1977),Priya(1978),Sigappu Rojakkal(1978)etc. If you are gonna name it as 80's rounds isnt it fair to just stick to that ??. What is the problem in naming the show Golden Hits of Ilaiyara as compared to Golden Hits of 80's??.Is it a crime to give credit to the composer ?? Unless the judges mention there's no mention at all about the composer which is sad :(.It also gives wrong info to the viewers that these songs were from the 80's when infact they are'nt.
In many websites and places ive seen IR wrongly credited for movies such as Varumaiyin Niram Sivappu,Apoorva Raagangal,Ninaithale Inikkum.They are such popular movies and its really unfair for both MSV and IR. People get info from so called trusted places and they also argue and vouch for it.I really have an issue with that.Its ok if its an unknown movie but definitely not for a film which is a popular one.
Ragamalika generally seems to be picking a hit music director/director combo or music director/actor combo and asking contestants to sing songs from the combo picked.For instance Ilaiyaraja/Bharathi Raja,Ilaiyaraja/Kamal Hassan etc.This is the only show where the viewers atleast get to know the composer of the song.
My main concern is why can't they display a small synopsis about the song such as the Name of the song,Film,Year,Music Director,Singers,Raga etc.It'll be educative value for those seeing the show and also if the song is great a small say about the intricacies of the song.This is where i appreciate the great SPB.Seldom has he refrained from not talking about a song and he also gives interesting background incidents.It was through him that we came to know how diffuclt the guitarist found it to play Ilaya Nila and the fact that it required 16 takes.All these info really gets you very participative and you look forward to the show.
My other concern is Why do the singers always choose popular songs??.There are so many hidden treasures and i was thinking this could be a great platform to unleash the brilliance of so many unheard songs of Maestro but alas they refuse to budge.
It is really nice to see so many musical shows on the small screen.But to sustain interest i beleive there should be a re-vamp in the structure in certain areas in order to continue having an impact.The sooner its done,the better.
7 comments:
Rajiv, You have hit the nail on the head.
Mr.Hariharan who always coaxes the participants to listen to all kinds of music and songs has to take a look at himself first.
The usual statement that 'I grew up in Bombay and therefore did not get an opportunity to listen to Tamizh Film music' will sound only like a dirty excuse.He is a musician and a 'Tamizhan'.
Moreover, if one can coolly listen to Bob Dylan and MJ sitting here, nothing should stop them from listening to the music from their own land.
Heal thyself Physician...
I too noticed that goof up regarding '80s.It is surprising because Subhashree Thanikachalam, the Director of the show is very knowledgeable.How she let this happen really beats me.
Even a normal Raaja fan knows when 'Sigappu RojakkaL' and 'Priya' were released..
As you said, participants have to sing more rare songs -though this does happen in Raagamalika at times.
Keep writing more.
Thanks,
Raj
Thanks a lot Raj for your comments..
I had the same concern, why the same 30 odd songs?!. There are so many gems, I hear them only rarely. Also IR's songs are not just about the main melody, getting orchestration right so important. It is not some ambient sound or some loop/beat playing behind. (one example I relished recently is Kathirukken kathava thirandhu, so much interplay of instruments literally flirting as the characters of the duet itself). The programs feature very lame instrumentation. - Kumar
Nice work...in airtel super singer, there was this happy-pathos round...the orchetra accompanyment was lousy i say...Vijay tv should change their orchestra for the show...the chords/bass etc were suicidal...the finer nuances that raaja brings about in the orchstration of a pathos song was totally lost by the clueless wretched orchestra...ignorant judges (sailaja, sowmya etc) kept asking whether it was a happy version or the sad version...Raja's songs can expose your ineeficiencies as a singer and as a instrument player....
Thanks Kumar for sharing your views..
Seems like many of us share the same view regarding the Rare songs thing..Hope they are listening and try to make the show more appealing by including some rare gems..
Thanks Vel for your comments..
I remember seeing the Happy-Pathos round and as you rightly pointed out the orchestration was sub standard..And the Different feel for the happy and pathos was point blank missing..Raja's orchestration is always a class apart and it is disappointing to see his songs being spoiled by poor orchestrarion.
@Raj
Interesting to note your views on Mr Hariharan..You very rightly pointed out that being a Tamizhan he ought to listen to Tamizh film music..The worst part is even the co-judges James and Sharath seem to know a lot more about Raja's music and its very disappointing to see a such an experienced singer like Hariharan being absolutely clueless when some old memorable Raja songs are being sung..
Post a Comment